My daughter had been suggesting I read this book for years. I think I avoided it because somewhere deep down I've always sympathized with the ugly stepsisters. I couldn't help but wonder what their lives would have been like with a different mother. The cover of this book gave me the impression that the stepsisters' story would be ugly indeed. And in some ways it is. The beginning of this book is harsh and dark, something out of a grim Dickens novel. In fact, nothing in this story rings of Fairy Tales. No Fairy Godmothers, magic pumpkins, and certainly no birds singing happy songs to anyone.(As in the movie.) The mother is a miserable woman who has no problem making her daughter's lives hell. The other characters are drawn in such a way that even though their lives were over-the-top awful, they seem real, and I genuinely cared about them. I especially liked the two painters, their predicaments and their problems.
One of the aspects I enjoyed was the fact that you know you have an unreliable narrator. Iris is certainly seeing, and telling, events through her own slanted, self-centered viewpoint. Trying to search out the truths in the story made it even more fascinating. I recommend this book, but it's not for children or those who can't read harsh, sometimes grim, material. For all that, it was still a good read, and I'll be thinking about the characters for some time.
Jul 23, 2008
The curse of beauty
I was surprised by how much I began to like this book the further I read into it. At the outset I was a little wary of the dry tone, thinking that Maguire was deliberately making his tale mundane, but soon the story began to center around the family relationships and the writing style warmed up. In the same philosophical manner he displayed in "Wicked," Maguire here dissects the nature of beauty, and of society's perception of and reaction to all things beautiful. What I appreciated most of all was how all of his characters behaved according to their own inner code. The "wicked" stepmother was completely believable and not even necessarily inherently wicked. Everything she did was driven by a survival instinct and her personality was what clashed with that of the Ashgirl so fiercely. Lastly, there is a small twist near the end that is incredibly well executed. It's a simple thing but it was a wonderful touch that put the entire book into startlingly clear perspective.
Apr 3, 2007
More than meets the eye...
This book is so much more than a simple re-imagining of the Cinderella story from the perspective of one of her Ugly Stepsisters. It has a unique charm all it's own.
The characters are all vibrant and alive. Nothing seems stereotypical or boring. It is a lush fairy tale grounded in the reality of the Holland in the 17th century.
The book also explores the nature of beauty. What makes a person beautiful? Is it their body, their face, or their soul? Is beauty something to be cherished, or something to be feared?
The style is accessible to modern readers, but still evokes the style and mores of 17th Century Holland. The book is captivating, rich, and, at times, downright creepy.
If you enjoy a good fairy tale, this book is for you. This book has a lot to offer for both young and mature readers. I'd also recommend it to anyone who liked GIRL WITH A PEARL EARRING.
Alibris, the Alibris logo, and Alibris.com are registered trademarks of Alibris, Inc.
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited, Baker & Taylor, Inc., or by their respective licensors, or by the publishers, or by their respective licensors. For personal use only. All rights reserved. All rights in images of books or other publications are reserved by the original copyright holders.